Skip main navigation
1 options

58 Houses for Rent near Shelter Island Heights

Shelter Island Heights, NY Houses for Rent

Page 2 / 2: 58 houses for rent

Newest
  • $5,000

    3 beds, 2 baths

    12 Wesley Ave

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $40k

    4 beds, 3 baths

    140 W Neck Rd

    House in Shelter Island Heights, NY

  • $25k

    4 beds, 4 baths

    37 Gardiners Bay Dr

    House in Shelter Island Heights, NY

  • $25k

    4 beds, 3.5 baths

    13 Dinah Rock Rd

     | Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $15k

    4 beds, 2 baths

    5 Mimosa Pl

     | Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $26k

    3 beds, 2.5 baths

    16 Glynn Dr

     | Rove Travel

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $4,500

    3 beds, 2 baths

    4 Ivy Pl

     | Corcoran Group

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $20k

    4 beds, 2 baths

    9 Johnston Rd

     | Brown Harris Stevens

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $9,000

    5 beds, 4 baths

    4 Summerfield Pl

     | Griffing & Collins Real Estate

    House in Shelter Island Heights, NY

  • $15k

    4 beds, 3 baths

    36 Gardiners Bay Dr

     | Dering Harbor Real Estate

    House in Shelter Island Heights, NY

  • $15k

    3 beds, 2 baths

    4 Great Circle Rd

     | Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $15k

    4 beds, 2.5 baths

    38 Brander Pkwy

    House in Shelter Island Heights, NY

  • $30k

    5 beds, 4.5 baths

    151 N Ferry Rd

    House in Shelter Island Heights, NY

  • $7,000

    3 beds, 2.5 baths

    7 Clinton Ave

     | Dering Harbor Real Estate

    House in Shelter Island Heights, NY

  • $50k

    3 beds, 3 baths

    28 Gardiners Bay Dr

     | Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $30k

    5 beds, 4 baths

    6 Cobbetts Ln

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $70k

    3 beds, 3 baths

    8 Chequit Ave

     | Saunders & Associates

    House in Shelter Island Heights, NY

  • $55k

    4 beds, 4 baths

    8 Clinton Ave

     | Dering Harbor Real Estate

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $13.2k

    3 beds, 1 bath

    91 Shore Rd

    House in Shelter Island Heights, NY

  • $4,500

    4 beds, 2 baths

    7 White Birch Rd

     | Dering Harbor Real Estate

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $75k

    6 beds, 4.5 baths

    15 Montclair Ave

     | Corcoran Group

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $7,500

    5 beds, 4 baths

    18 Clinton Ave

     | Dering Harbor Real Estate

    House in Shelter Island Heights, NY

  • Call

    5 beds, 2 baths

    26 Winthrop Rd

     | Dering Harbor Real Estate

    House in Shelter Island, NY

If you're able to expand your search outside of Shelter Island Heights, check out properties in these nearby areas:
East Marion
25 properties
  • $8,000

    3 beds, 1.5 baths

    460 Bay Ave

    House in East Marion, NY

  • $79k

    3 beds, 3 baths

    (Undisclosed Address)

    House in East Marion, NY

  • $10k

    4 beds, 2.5 baths

    2905 Private Rd

    House in East Marion, NY

  • $15k

    3 beds, 2.5 baths

    3670 Rocky Point Rd

     | Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    House in East Marion, NY

Greenport
22 properties
  • $8,000

    4 beds, 3.5 baths

    1510 Maple Ln

    House in Greenport, NY

  • $5,000

    3 beds, 4 baths

    145 Sterling St

     | Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    House in Greenport, NY

  • $4,350

    3 beds, 2 baths

    311 5th St

    House in Greenport, NY

  • $45k

    4 beds, 2.5 baths

    619 Bailey Ave

     | Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty

    House in Greenport, NY

Town of Shelter Island
90 properties
  • $86k

    4 beds, 3.5 baths

    23 Osprey Rd

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $42k

    4 beds, 3 baths

    5 Heron Ln

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $35k

    3 beds, 2 baths

    6 Cozy Ln

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $8,000

    3 beds, 3 baths

    19 Peconic Ave

    House in Shelter Island, NY

Shelter Island
90 properties
  • $86k

    4 beds, 3.5 baths

    23 Osprey Rd

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $42k

    4 beds, 3 baths

    5 Heron Ln

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $35k

    3 beds, 2 baths

    6 Cozy Ln

    House in Shelter Island, NY

  • $8,000

    3 beds, 3 baths

    19 Peconic Ave

    House in Shelter Island, NY

North Haven
50 properties
  • New 4d ago
    $9,000

    3 beds, 2 baths

    31 Bayberry Ln

     | Compass

    House in Sag Harbor, NY

  • $187k

    5 beds, 5.5 baths

    24 On The Blf

     | Corcoran Group

    House in Sag Harbor, NY

  • $110k

    6 beds, 6.5 baths

    8 Widow Coopers Path

     | Compass

    House in Sag Harbor, NY

  • $52.5k

    4 beds, 4.5 baths

    12 Cedar Ave

     | Compass

    House in Sag Harbor, NY

Rendered Server Side.

Searching for houses to rent in Shelter Island Heights is easy when you utilize HotPads map-based search platform. Browse through 58 house rentals throughout Shelter Island Heights’s most popular neighborhoods and hotspots. In hot markets like Shelter Island Heights, it’s important to move fast and contact the newest listings ASAP. We make it easy with our one-click contact form so you can quickly send your next inquiry.

We know house hunting is personal and everyone has different needs so let HotPads do the heavy lifting by setting your specific filters that include bedroom and bathroom counts, price range, square footage, and many more. Looking for pet friendly rentals or places with in-unit laundry? Just specify in your filters. Or have a tight deadline and need to move before a certain date? Search by availability dates. Want to keep up on the latest rentals available in Shelter Island Heights? Save your search filters with the “Save search” button to receive the freshest house recommendations as they come on-market.

If you’re looking for a deal, find listings that have had ‘Price Drops’ and watch for listings with a "Promo" tag by searching “Promos” within the filters. We’ve also made it easy to find that perfect luxury house or affordable rentals by visiting our cheap Shelter Island Heights houses.