All rentals
Apartments
Condos
Houses
Townhomes
Duplexes
Rooms
List your rental
Pay your rent
Get help

Shelter Island, NY Rentals

No rentals found

Apartments near me
Houses near me
About us
Terms of use
Privacy Notice
Ad Choices
Help

Feeds
List your rental
Sitemap
Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information

Zillow Group is committed to ensuring digital accessibility for individuals with disabilities. We are continuously working to improve the accessibility of our web experience for everyone, and welcome feedback and accommodation requests. If you wish to report an issue or seek an accommodation please contact us at support@hotpads.com

Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity

Fair Housing Guide

© 2026 HotPads

Shelter Island Snapshot

Demographic highlights

Total population: 2,412 people

Market highlights

Median rent: $20,000
Median rent, monthly change: -6.98%

Near me

Rentals near me
Places for rent near me
Cheap apartments near me
1 Bedroom apartments near me
Apartments near me
Houses near me
Condos near me
Townhomes near me
Rooms near me
Duplexes near me

Price

Affordable apartments in Shelter Island
Luxury apartments in Shelter Island

Beds

2 bedroom apartments in Shelter Island
3 bedroom apartments in Shelter Island
4 bedroom apartments in Shelter Island

Amenities

Apartments with laundry in Shelter Island
Apartments with parking in Shelter Island
Apartments with loft in Shelter Island
Apartments with pool in Shelter Island
Apartments with air conditioning in Shelter Island
Apartments with heating in Shelter Island

Property types

Apartments for rent in Shelter Island
New apartments for rent in Shelter Island
New houses for rent in Shelter Island
Furnished houses for rent in Shelter Island
Condos for rent in Shelter Island
Private landlord owned rentals in Shelter Island
Houses for rent by owner in Shelter Island

Cities near Shelter Island

Furnished apartments for rent in Town of Southampton
Furnished apartments for rent in Groton
Furnished apartments for rent in Town of Riverhead
Furnished apartments for rent in Branford
Furnished apartments for rent in New London
Furnished apartments for rent in Riverhead
Furnished apartments for rent in Town of Southold
Furnished apartments for rent in Shelter Island Heights
Furnished apartments for rent in Town of Shelter Island
Furnished apartments for rent in Greenport
Furnished apartments for rent in East Marion
Furnished apartments for rent in Southold
Furnished apartments for rent in Orient
Furnished apartments for rent in Cutchogue
Furnished apartments for rent in New Suffolk

Counties near Shelter Island

Kings County furnished apartments
Queens County furnished apartments
New York County furnished apartments
Middlesex County furnished apartments
Suffolk County furnished apartments
Bronx County furnished apartments
Nassau County furnished apartments
New London County furnished apartments
New Haven County furnished apartments
Washington County furnished apartments
Tolland County furnished apartments
Hartford County furnished apartments
Windham County furnished apartments
Fairfield County furnished apartments
Kent County furnished apartments

Schools near Shelter Island

Shelter Island School apartments
Greenport Elementary School apartments
Greenport High School apartments
Oysterponds Elementary School apartments
New Suffolk School apartments
Southold Elementary School apartments
Southold Junior Senior High School apartments
Mattituck Junior Senior High School apartments
Mattituck Cutchogue Elementary School apartments
Kathleen E. Goodwin School apartments

Universities near Shelter Island

Mitchell College apartments
University of Connecticut-Avery Point apartments
United States Coast Guard Academy apartments
Connecticut College apartments
Yale University apartments
Albertus Magnus College apartments
University of New Haven apartments
Southern Connecticut State University apartments
Wesleyan University apartments
Quinnipiac University apartments
Holy Apostles College and Seminary apartments
University of Connecticut-Waterbury Campus apartments
Post University apartments
American Sentinel College of Nursing and Health Sciences apartments

Zip codes near Shelter Island

11901 furnished apartments
06340 furnished apartments
06320 furnished apartments
06437 furnished apartments
06443 furnished apartments
11946 furnished apartments
06385 furnished apartments
11964 furnished apartments
11965 furnished apartments
11944 furnished apartments
11939 furnished apartments
11971 furnished apartments
11957 furnished apartments
11935 furnished apartments
11952 furnished apartments