Highlights
Central A/C
No parking
Pool
Listed 1 month ago
Updated 1 month ago
1/19
N Cartwright Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
$36k
4
Beds
3.5
Baths
2554
Sqft
Doesn't include required deposits and fees
Commute
Loading
Loading commute times...
About this listing
Rental Registration #: 2025-L-0043 Located within close proximity to harbor and beach, this traditional offers a great room with vaulted ceilings, chef's kitchen, first floor bedroom and second floor with three additional bedrooms and office area. The grounds offer privacy and a beautiful in-ground pool with decking - new to the rental market for 2026 season!
Apartment amenities
Property amenities
- Architecture Style: traditional
- Basement
- Central Air Conditioning
- Fireplace
- Lot Size: 0.69
- MLS Listing ID: 391355
- Parking Type: none
- Stories: 2
- Swimming Pool
- Year Built: 2005
Pet policy
Pet policy information isn't provided.
Pricing comparison
$11,000At $36,000, this listing is priced $11,000 more than the current market rate for a 4 bedroom home in Town of Shelter Island.
Other 4 bedroom homes...
- in Town of Shelter Island go for $25,000
- in Suffolk County go for $33,028
- in 11964 go for $25,000
Nearby schools
Students who live near this listing attend the following Shelter Island Union Free School District (Unified School District) public schools:
AllMixed
Showing 1 of
1 school.
GreatSchools ratings are based on test scores and additional metrics when available.
By contacting this property, you agree to our Terms of Use. Visit our Privacy Portal for more information. When you click "Send message", we'll send your inquiry to the property manager so they can reach out and answer your questions.