How many apartment units are available and what are their rents?

There are 2 two-bedroom apartments available starting at $965

What is the apartment building's pet policy?

There are cats allowed at Bay Colony I.

Is there laundry in the building?

This building offers in unit laundry.

Does the building offer parking?

Yes, Bay Colony I provides parking.

What Whitefish Bay neighborhood is Bay Colony I in?

Your new apartment would be located in the Whitefish Bay neighborhood.

When was this listing last updated?

The property manager updated this rental listing 1 minute, 19 seconds ago.

Back to search results

Back to search

Updated 1 minute ago

$965/mo

Bay Colony I, 189-203 E Fairmount Ave, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

2 bd1 ba850 sqft

Apartment

Loading reviews

Updated 1 minute ago

$965/mo

Bay Colony I, 189-203 E Fairmount Ave, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

2 bd1 ba850 sqft

Apartment

Loading reviews

What you get

Status: ParkingStatus: Cat-friendlyStatus: In-unit laundryStatus: Administrative Fee: 0Status: Building Application Fee: 25

Units available in this building

2 Beds • 1 bath • 850 sqft
Unit Rent/mo Available Unit details
$965 12/12/2026
$965 Now

Unit	Rent/mo	Available	Unit details
	$965	12/12/2026	›
	$965	Now	›

2 Beds • 1 bath • 850 sqft
Unit Rent/mo Available Unit details
$965 12/12/2026
$965 Now

Unit	Rent/mo	Available	Unit details
	$965	12/12/2026	›
	$965	Now	›

Unit	Rent/mo	Available	Unit details
	$965	12/12/2026	›
	$965	Now	›

Unit	Rent/mo	Available	Unit details
	$965	12/12/2026	›
	$965	Now	›

Nearby schools

Students who live in Bay Colony I attend the following Whitefish Bay School District public schools:

10
Cumberland Elementary School
Public, Grades PK - 5
0.7 mi
10
Whitefish Bay Middle School
Public, Grades 6 - 8
0.8 mi
10
Whitefish Bay High School
Public, Grades 9 - 12
0.8 mi

GreatSchools ratings are based on test scores and additional metrics when available. ...

Find similar homes

Similar listings	This listing Bay Colony I	Apex Apartments	Maple Crest Senior Apartments	Springhill Apartments	The Aspen	Hickory Gardens	Park Village Apartments

Bay Colony I, 189-203 E Fairmount Ave, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

Bay Colony I, 189-203 E Fairmount Ave, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

What you get

Units available in this building

Bay Colony I, 189-203 E Fairmount Ave, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

Units available in this building

What people say

Costs, fees, and lease terms

Costs, fees, and lease terms

Pets

Competition for this rental

The neighborhood

About the building

Nearby schools

Cumberland Elementary School

Whitefish Bay Middle School

Whitefish Bay High School

Cumberland Elementary School

Whitefish Bay Middle School

Whitefish Bay High School

Find similar homes

Bay Colony I

Apex Apartments

Maple Crest Senior Apartments

Springhill Apartments

The Aspen

Hickory Gardens

Park Village Apartments

More from this provider

Most popular nearby

Pet-friendly rentals nearby

Recently viewed homes

Frequently asked questions

The property manager

Costs, fees, and lease terms

About the building

Frequently asked questions