32 Oakland Ave

32 Oakland Ave — Photo 1
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 2
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 3
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 4
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 5
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 6
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 7
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 8
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 9
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 10
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 11
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 12
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 13
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 14
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 15
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 16
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 17
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 18
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 19
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 20
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 21
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 22
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 23
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 24
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 25
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 26
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 27
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 28
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 29
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 30
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 31
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 32
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 33
32 Oakland Ave — Photo 34

$100k/ mo
Doesn't include deposits and fees
5 beds3.5 baths2900 sqft house
32 Oakland Ave

Your booked tour

What you get

ParkingAir conditioningPool

Costs, fees, and lease terms

The neighborhood

About the building

Offered for the first time as a rental, this is truly one of the most beautiful and special homes in Sag Harbor Village-an unparalleled summer escape. Tucked away in the heart of Sag Harbor Village, this exceptionally charming and private retreat offers a rare opportunity to experience waterfront living at its finest. Set on 2/3 of an acre and centered on Otter Pond, the home enjoys serene open water views from almost every room, lush mature landscaping, and a sense of tranquility that feels worlds away-yet situated in the heart of town and moments from village shops, restaurants, and marinas. Designed for both relaxation and entertaining, the property features a large pool, an expansive veranda perfect for al fresco dining, and multiple indoor living spaces including three beautifully appointed living rooms filled with natural light. Additional highlights include a dedicated home office, a gym, and a garage for added convenience.Current Availability:Off Season (9/8/26-4/30/27): $175,000Year round: $325,000

The property manager

32 Oakland Ave

By contacting this property, you agree to our Terms of Use. Visit our Privacy Portal for more information. When you click “Send message”, we’ll send your inquiry to the property manager so they can reach out and answer your questions.

Find similar homes

Spot something off?Good catch. Flag it and help keep listings legit.