Contact

256 Prospect Valley Rd

Upstairs Middle Room ( possibly 4th bedroom)
No closet

Kitchen, laundry room entrance on left , bathroom on right

Living room with wood burning fireplace , view from kitchen

Downstairs Master Bedroom with 2 closets

Master bedroom entrance doorways off the kitchen , steps on right to enter upstairs bedrooms

Creek runs behind the property , fishing allowed

Downstairs master bedroom small closet , off the kitchen

Laundry room with bay window, tub sink and extra cabinet storage
Washer/Dryer included

Master bedroom downstairs with 2nd small closet

Mud Room with electric outlet to enter front door
Under renovation currently

Master Bedroom , new walls, molding and flooring

Kitchen sink with window that looks out to pond

Steps to upstairs bedrooms, steep, narrow

Kitchen view of living room , new recessed lighting

Living room with wood burning fireplace , 4 windows

open room upstairs possible 4th bedroom or office

Windowsill looking to pond in laundry room

Updated 19 hours agoListed Jul 26

$2,000/ mo

Doesn't include deposits and fees

3 beds1 bath2000 sqft house

Available September 1

256 Prospect Valley Rd

Your booked tour

What you get

Pet-friendlyIn-unit laundryParkingAir conditioning

Costs, fees, and lease terms

Special offer!

The pole barn is included in the monthly rental fee

Lease terms

1 year lease Tenant Pays All Utilities to include electric, propane heat and wood (electric, gas and fireplace), garbage, renters insurance Rental has well water Security deposit plus 1st month's rent Non-Smoker only Pet friendly (cat/dog)with proof of consistent Vet care/license No ATV riding is allowed on the property

Pricing comparison

$305

At $2,000, this listing is priced $305 more than the current market rate for a 3 bedroom home in Willseyville.

Other 3 bedroom homes in the area go for

Willseyville$1,695
Tioga County$1,905
13864$1,695

Pets

The neighborhood

About the building

CURRENTLY OCCUPIED, TENANT MOVES OUT AUG 23rd 2026. AFTER TENANT MOVES THERE WILL BE MORE AVAILABILITY FOR SHOWINGS.… NO SCHEDULING VIA ZILLOW - APPOINTMENTS BY PHONE CALL ONLY SOME OF THE PICS ARE OLDER, PRIOR TO REMODELING. WILL UPDATE RECENT PICS WHEN TENANT MOVES Rental Terms: 4 -5 person MAX capacity including children - Long term rental applicants are preferred - No short-term lease - 1-year lease required - $2000 a month - Security deposit and first month's rent required - Proof of renters insurance is required - Tenant is responsible for all yard and pond maintenance. A working tractor is supplied by the landlord - Must agree to 2 -3 scheduled home safety inspections/pest control care per year - Non Smokers only -Pet Friendly home (cat/dog only accepted ) Application Requirements: - credit score 650 or higher history is highly preferred -Monthly Income requirement is at least 3 x monthly rent for adult applicants - Background check each adult with no felony conviction - Proof of income, plus proof of a 3 year steady employment history. Tenant must be agreeable to a work background check - 1 Personal Reference Required per each adult applicant -2 Previous Landlord Recommendations to include the past 5 years with no prior eviction judgement -Tenant must be physically capable to perform all yard maintenance and snow removal - Pet veterinary vaccination records for past 2 years We prefer our own prescreening process outside of Zillow, tenant must agree to provide required information in a timely manner for consideration Want out of city life, more of a country lifestyle but close enough to the city, this old farmhouse property is for you. Right off the main highway between Candor and Ithica NY. Dream of fresh eggs from your chickens, fishing anytime from the pond and creek side. Maybe raise a cow or 2! Candor School District County Living in Willseyville NY Older recenly renovated home on a large beautiful quiet spacious property with a pond and creek access on backside of house The yard is huge, plenty of room to grow your own garden Farming possibilities SMALL OLD FARMHOUSE WITH DETACHED 2 CAR GARAGE/ LARGE POLE BARN recently renovated last year. Current tenant is moving out Aug 31st 2026. Available September 1st 2026. Located just 20-25 minutes from downtown Ithaca, this peaceful old country property offers lots of outdoor space, comfort, and character. This home is older, floors are a tad slanted with narrow steep steps to enter upstairs bedrooms. ( Your king/Queen bed will not fit upstairs and all your furniture should to be small scale ) If you appreciate a older home charm , please check it out. Property was previously farmed with cows years ago thus the old pole barn. If you are looking for a modern home this rental is probably not the right fit for you. Total square footage not available at this time. Property Features: - 3 bedrooms, with potential for a 4th (Max capacity 4-5 MAX people including children) - 1 small full bathroom (located on the 1st floor) - Laundry room with newer washer and dryer included - Detached 2-car garage with small workshop - Newer garage doors - Kitchen includes newer refrigerator and stove - Large yard with a serene pond and creek - New propane heating system, plus a cozy wood-burning fireplace in the living room - Single Electric baseboard heating in upstairs bedrooms - Old very large pole barn in backyard - Mud room to enter front door Pet Policy: - Maximum of 2 pets (dog and/or cat only) preferred with proof of routine annual veterinary care

The property manager

Nearby schools

Students who live in 256 Prospect Valley Rd attend the following Candor Central School District (Unified School District) public schools:

8
Candor Junior Senior High School
Public, Grades 7 - 12
1.6 mi
3
Candor Elementary School
Public, Grades K - 6
1.6 mi

GreatSchools ratings are based on test scores and additional metrics when available.