23 Tuthill Dr

Just moments from the water's edge, this coastal haven is steps from the tranquil shores of Coecles Harbor, offering partial water views and an easy walk or bike ride to the island's pristine beaches, beloved eateries, and local shops. Whether you're seeking a serene family retreat, a stylish getaway with friends, or a restorative solo sojourn, this three-bedroom, three-bathroom home promises a sophisticated yet relaxed experiencedesigned to transport guests away from the everyday and into the Shelter Island state of mind.The experience begins the moment you arrive. The home is nestled within a spacious, fully fenced yard, enveloped by lush greenery that ensures the utmost privacy. Guests are greeted by an expansive outdoor oasis complete with a private, heated pool surrounded by chaise lounge chairsthe perfect spot for sun-drenched afternoons. As the sun begins to dip, the firepit beckons, inviting intimate conversations under a blanket of stars. The outdoor dining area, gas grill, and lounge seating set the scene for al fresco dinners, cocktail hours, and long, leisurely mornings with coffee in hand. Every element has been curated with comfort and connection in mind, making the outdoor space as memorable as the interiors. And with ample off-street parking, hosting is always effortless.Step inside, and the magic continues. The home's interior is flooded with natural light, thanks to large windows that frame serene views of the surrounding greenery. A double-sided central fireplace anchors the space, offering warmth and ambiance in both of the home's two stylish living rooms. Each space is thoughtfully designed to blend chic design with cozy comfort, inviting guests to unwind with a glass of wine, curl up with a good book, or gather for a family movie night. The kitchen is fully updated and equipped with everything a home chef could desirefrom high-end appliances to a spacious island perfect for entertaining. Whether preparing a gourmet meal or whipping up a simple beach picnic, the space is as functional as it is beautiful. For those balancing leisure and productivity, the home includes two dedicated work-from-home spaces, reliable high-speed WiFi, and the comforts of central air conditioning, a washer and dryer, Sonos speaker system, and all the essentials for modern island living.Each of the three bedrooms offers a private sanctuary designed for restful sleep and rejuvenation. Outfitted with fresh, hotel-quality linens and an abundance of windows, every bedroom invites natural light and sweeping views of the surrounding landscape. The primary suite is a true retreat, complete with a king bed, spa-like ensuite bathroom featuring a soaking tub and a walk-in shower, and a peaceful ambiance that makes it hard to leave. The two guest bedrooms each feature plush queen beds, designer touches, and convenient access to full bathroomsproviding a perfect layout for families or groups traveling together.Beyond the home, Shelter Island unfolds like a well-kept secret, offering endless ways to explore and indulge. Start your day with a walk or bike ride to nearby Crescent Beach or Wades Beach for a swim or a morning paddleboard. Then stroll into town to discover charming boutiques, art galleries, and gourmet markets. Enjoy a locally-sourced lunch at Vine Street Cafe, or sip wine in the garden at Salt. For a cultural fix, visit the Shelter Island Historical Society or take a ferry ride to the North or South Fork for vineyard tours and more culinary adventures. And at day's end, return to your peaceful retreat, where the sounds of nature and the glow of the firepit remind you that this isn't just a vacationit's a way of life.This Shelter Island getaway is more than a place to stayit's a curated experience for those who appreciate thoughtful design, natural beauty, and the luxury of slowing down.