$8,000/ mo
Doesn't include deposits and fees
3 beds2 baths1500 sqft house
18 Hay Beach Rd
Back to search
Contact
18 Hay Beach Rd
Your booked tour
What you get
Costs, fees, and lease terms
Pricing comparison
$7094At $8,000, this listing is priced $7094 cheaper than the current market rate for a 3 bedroom home in Town of Shelter Island.
Other 3 bedroom homes in the area go for
- Town of Shelter Island$15,094
- Suffolk County$20,000
- 11965$15,094
The neighborhood
About the building
Rental Registration #: 2026_L-0052 Romantically lovely home with three bedrooms, two baths, living room with vaulted ceiling and masonry fireplace.… Update chef's kitchen. Large deck. Lower level lounge and a one car garage. Short distance to popular Mehanden Lane Beach. Available for Summer 2026 and beyond!
The property manager
Nearby schools
Students who live in 18 Hay Beach Rd attend the following Shelter Island Union Free School District (Unified School District) public schools:
- 62.8 mi
Shelter Island School
Public, Grades PK - 12
GreatSchools ratings are based on test scores and additional metrics when available.
18 Hay Beach Rd
By contacting this property, you agree to our Terms of Use. Visit our Privacy Portal for more information. When you click “Send message”, we’ll send your inquiry to the property manager so they can reach out and answer your questions.
Find similar homes
Spot something off?Good catch. Flag it and help keep listings legit.