Apartments for rent in Shelter Island NY
34 apartments for rent
34 apartments for rent
Dering Harbor Traditional Victorian residence, brilliantly restored and carefully expanded, offers classic details - extraordinary wide plank floors, elegant moldings, window and door trim and a classic fireplace. Double parlors, formal dining room, gorgeous eat-in-kitchen and prep kitchen outfitted for easy entertaining leads to a spacious screened porch overlooking lush garden and heated gunite pool. There are 5 bedrooms, including a luxurious master, 3 1/2 baths . Truly a dream house - restored and appointed with an artist's eye offering the best in taste, comfort = CAC and set in a romantic, private garden with inviting pool within the village. An expansive deep water dock supplements this extraordinary property - truly a boaters dream house.
Bright and open 4 bedroom 3 bath contemporary home with a spacious floor plan and plenty of exterior areas for lounging and barbecuing on the deck or by the heated pool. The partially finished basement and game room will be fun for the kids. Well equipped with central air, cable/internet, fireplace, garage, outdoor shower, hot tub & heated pool. July $25,000; August $27,000; August-LD $30,000.
Rental Registration #: 2023-l-0033 Shelter Island is nestled between the North and South Forks of eastern Long Island. This newly constructed 3-bedroom farmhouse, situated on a private .94 acre of property, is located just 2 minutes from the North Ferry making it easy to head over for a visit to the Seaport town of Greenport. In Greenport you will find plenty of shops, galleries and restaurants to enjoy. You can also take a wine tasting tour of the many vineyards along the North Fork. The home is located just one mile from beautiful sunsets at Crescent Beach which hosts Sunset Beach Restaurant. You can dine at Leon 1909, stop in at the Tuck Shop for Ice Cream, or play a round of golf at Shelter Island Country Club, all are within walking distance of the residence. There are so many lovely places on the Island to dine such as The Chequit, The Pridwin, The Rams Head Inn, Stars Cafe, Salt and the Eccentric Bagal just to name a few. All are just minutes away. If you like craft beer the Island has its own Shelter Island Brewery, or you can stop in at White Oak farm and enjoy some of the wines and cheeses that they offer. The South Ferry brings you into the Seaport town of Sag Harbor where you can find Bay Street Theater, Sag Harbor Cinema with its third-floor rooftop terrace bar "The Green Room", and tons of shops and dining experiences. Relaxation is plentiful while you enjoy life between the ferries at either one of the islands scenic beaches, hiking amongst nature in Mashomack Preserve or hanging around the house. The living Room is open to the kitchen allowing fireplace views from every angle of the main living area. The rear patio is equipped with a propane fire pit. The primary bedroom also has its own fireplace and boasts a large private bath with soaking tub and walk in shower. All bedrooms are suite style and are equipped with smart tv's. There is a large media room on the second floor, and you will find a billiard room at the lowest level that is equipped with a wet bar for entertaining. The garage has a small indoor basketball court for exercise on rainy days. The home is fitted with a Sonos system for music and has WIFI access points on each floor as well as outside. The home is ready to go for the summer season and can also be available for 15-day stays.
Rental Registration #: RRN: 2022-L-0017. RRN: 2022-L-0017. PEPPERMILL LANE: Beautifully maintained log-cabin home with chef's kitchen, vaulted ceilings, stone fireplace, hardwood floors, swimming pool, and large decks overlooking a fresh water pond teaming with wildlife. Available for rent for Summer 2024 Please email for additional information.
Rental Registration #: 2023-L-0175 Beautifully custom designed traditional with 3 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms. On an acre of land, this spacious residence on the main level has an open floor plan, bright spacious chef's kitchen with Viking 6-burner stove, a dining area and living room with fireplace, office, and a powder room. The two large sliders lead out to the backyard overlooking pool area and professionally designed landscaping. Free shaped pool has plenty of space for entertaining overlooking mesmerizing sunsets. Second floor has master en-suite bedroom with oversized double sink bathroom, huge shower and jacuzzi tub. Ample space in master walk-in closet. Two additional bedrooms with shared bathroom on the second floor. Attached 2 space garage with unfinished second floor, and space for additional parking outside. Solar panels maximize energy efficiency. Conveniently located minutes to beaches, golf, stores and restaurants in both Shelter Island Town and Shelter Island Heights, this house has everything you need.
Rental Registration #: 20-L-0700 Heavenly four bedroom, 2.5 bath retreat. Beautiful grounds, overlooking pond and sculpture garden. Peaceful cul-de-sac. Large deck, cathedral entrance, breakfast room with bay windows and view. Bike to the beach or town in minutes. Professional-level Kawai grand piano. Fireplace. A perfect retreat!
This lovely Shelter Island shingle style was originally built in 1860 and has been much improved with modern amenities while retaining the essence of the Island. Huge kitchen area with dining table, lounging area and fireplace with multiple french doors out to the extensive decking. Two additional separate living rooms on the 1st floor. Large master suite with fireplace and three guest bedrooms and bathroom on second floor. Very spacious home with room for all your loved ones set on 1.3 acres with lovely pool area and private yard. Close to Hay Beach, town center and the Heights and moments to the water this will be a summer to cherish for years to come! Please call with any questions about this property.
Perfect summer location on Shelter Island, with a large deck and private beach access. Enjoy this updated and modern 3 bedroom 2 bath home with CAC, fireplace, outdoor shower, light and open floor plan. Available May $17,000; June $23,000; July $35,000; August $40,000; MD-LD $88,000.
Rental Registration #: Pending Experience the ultimate in tranquility and luxury at this secluded oasis, where every moment is a picturesque escape. Discover breathtaking panoramic water views and soak in the mesmerizing sunrise & sunsets over Gardiner's Bay from just about every room in the house. Boasting an impressive layout featuring an open plan den/media room, dining room, and chef's kitchen-all thoughtfully designed to immerse you in the beauty of the surrounding waters. Expansive waterfront decks filer out of every room. A guest bedroom and a full bath finish off the ground floor. The second floor consists of an oversized primary suite with private deck and breath-taking views of the bay. An additional guest suite and laundry room complete this floor. The outdoors also envelops you with luxury: a waterside heated infinity pool, multiple covered porches for dining or relaxing, dining pavilion, and built-in gas grill. The meticulously landscaped garden blooms all summer long, and features professional landscape lighting. You'll be enchanted by this garden's beauty day and night. Take full advantage of this magnificent waterfront property. Your oasis awaits.
Charming, updated, old mixed with new. Located in Historic Shelter Island Heights and near the beautiful Union Chapel, a short distance from North Ferry and minutes from restaurants, pharmacy and shopping. Comfortable furnishings, crisp linens and outside dining with fire pit. 3 large beds and a set of bunk beds are perfect for larger groups. Available June 1-15 $6,000; 8/19-LD $14,000: 8/10-8/24 $12,000.
Dering Harbor Traditional Victorian residence, brilliantly restored and carefully expanded, offers classic details - extraordinary wide plank floors, elegant moldings, window and door trim and a classic fireplace. Double parlors, formal dining room, gorgeous eat-in-kitchen and prep kitchen outfitted for easy entertaining leads to a spacious screened porch overlooking lush garden and heated gunite pool. There are 5 bedrooms, including a luxurious master, 3 1/2 baths . Truly a dream house - restored and appointed with an artist's eye offering the best in taste, comfort = CAC and set in a romantic, private garden with inviting pool within the village. An expansive deep water dock supplements this extraordinary property - truly a boaters dream house.
Bright and open 4 bedroom 3 bath contemporary home with a spacious floor plan and plenty of exterior areas for lounging and barbecuing on the deck or by the heated pool. The partially finished basement and game room will be fun for the kids. Well equipped with central air, cable/internet, fireplace, garage, outdoor shower, hot tub & heated pool. July $25,000; August $27,000; August-LD $30,000.
Shelter Island Manor a luxurious, secluded estate which sits on eight sprawling and very private acres. The property encompasses two separatedwellings, a heated pool, outdoor shower, two-car garage accessed by a wide pebbled drive which can accommodate parking for 6-8 cars. Both homes on the property are professionally designed and decorated to be luxurious and welcoming, making this the ideal place to relax and entertain all summer long.In the 3-bedroom/2.5-bathroom main house, claim a space in front of the living room's fireplace, or find a place to call your own in the plush family room, private library, or serene screened porch near the garden. For even more privacy, escape to the master suite, with its own home office. Create a feast for the whole family in the large eat-in kitchen, which features a sub-zero, Viking stove (with a second refrigerator in the butler's pantry), two dishwashers, and two sinks. Then pass the plates and linger over a leisurely meal in the sun-soaked dining room or move to the slate terrace, which has a table that comfortably accommodates eight.The 2-bedroom/2.5-bathroom cottage is also professionally appointed and equipped with its own office, perfect for guests who want a bit more private space. The cottage boasts its own kitchen, complete with refrigerator, dishwasher, and two-burner stove. On the second floor, find the property's additional washer/dryer unit.Shelter Island Manor's gardens, with its large lawns and mature trees beckon for those who crave quiet time in nature, away from the city's chaos. A professional lighting system enhances the evening experience as does a professionally installed Sonos sound system with multiple zones inside and out. The property's heated pool is reminiscent of a pond, set in a very large, private enclosure with sea grasses and local shrubs. It is secluded and separate from the two dwellings, making it a perfect and very private spot for an early morning or midnight swim. For those preferring the beach, there is a small and quiet beach a 5 minute walk from the house; an outdoor shower will be at the ready when you return.
Rental Registration #: Pending Experience the ultimate in tranquility and luxury at this secluded oasis, where every moment is a picturesque escape. Discover breathtaking panoramic water views and soak in the mesmerizing sunrise & sunsets over Gardiner's Bay from just about every room in the house. Boasting an impressive layout featuring an open plan den/media room, dining room, and chef's kitchen-all thoughtfully designed to immerse you in the beauty of the surrounding waters. Expansive waterfront decks filer out of every room. A guest bedroom and a full bath finish off the ground floor. The second floor consists of an oversized primary suite with private deck and breath-taking views of the bay. An additional guest suite and laundry room complete this floor. The outdoors also envelops you with luxury: a waterside heated infinity pool, multiple covered porches for dining or relaxing, dining pavilion, and built-in gas grill. The meticulously landscaped garden blooms all summer long, and features professional landscape lighting. You'll be enchanted by this garden's beauty day and night. Take full advantage of this magnificent waterfront property. Your oasis awaits.
Charming, updated, old mixed with new. Located in Historic Shelter Island Heights and near the beautiful Union Chapel, a short distance from North Ferry and minutes from restaurants, pharmacy and shopping. Comfortable furnishings, crisp linens and outside dining with fire pit. 3 large beds and a set of bunk beds are perfect for larger groups. Available June 1-15 $6,000; 8/19-LD $14,000: 8/10-8/24 $12,000.
Shelter Island Manor a luxurious, secluded estate which sits on eight sprawling and very private acres. The property encompasses two separatedwellings, a heated pool, outdoor shower, two-car garage accessed by a wide pebbled drive which can accommodate parking for 6-8 cars. Both homes on the property are professionally designed and decorated to be luxurious and welcoming, making this the ideal place to relax and entertain all summer long.In the 3-bedroom/2.5-bathroom main house, claim a space in front of the living room's fireplace, or find a place to call your own in the plush family room, private library, or serene screened porch near the garden. For even more privacy, escape to the master suite, with its own home office. Create a feast for the whole family in the large eat-in kitchen, which features a sub-zero, Viking stove (with a second refrigerator in the butler's pantry), two dishwashers, and two sinks. Then pass the plates and linger over a leisurely meal in the sun-soaked dining room or move to the slate terrace, which has a table that comfortably accommodates eight.The 2-bedroom/2.5-bathroom cottage is also professionally appointed and equipped with its own office, perfect for guests who want a bit more private space. The cottage boasts its own kitchen, complete with refrigerator, dishwasher, and two-burner stove. On the second floor, find the property's additional washer/dryer unit.Shelter Island Manor's gardens, with its large lawns and mature trees beckon for those who crave quiet time in nature, away from the city's chaos. A professional lighting system enhances the evening experience as does a professionally installed Sonos sound system with multiple zones inside and out. The property's heated pool is reminiscent of a pond, set in a very large, private enclosure with sea grasses and local shrubs. It is secluded and separate from the two dwellings, making it a perfect and very private spot for an early morning or midnight swim. For those preferring the beach, there is a small and quiet beach a 5 minute walk from the house; an outdoor shower will be at the ready when you return.
Tasteful and stylish, this 4BR , 4BA Contemporary offers large open floor plan, a library, den, and office. The large open Great Room with fireplace, vaulted ceiling leads to the entertaining deck with pool. Kitchen has terra cotta floors, granite counters, and chef quality appliances. Sky lights are throughout both floors that brings in lots of natural light. Beautiful tiered gardens surround the house and is central to shopping, restaurants and beaches. July $35,000.
Rental Registration #: 2024-L-0009 Paradise Found. A waterfront splendor. Where modern meets magical. Stepping into this modern barn style home begins an experience of inspiration. Surrounded by water and actually built over water, this 3 bedroom retreat is an architectural treat. Masterfully renovated by its owner, a nautical feel is evident throughout. Outdoor features include harbor side deck and grill, outdoor lounging beckons. There is an airstream on site as well as a sauna. Interior mastery includes upcyled barn siding in the main bedroom, soaring ceiling heights, and 3 bedrooms nicely spaced for a great sense of flow and privacy. No better place to escape to. The dock is a floating dock and you can bring your own boat. Depth is 30" at low tide. There is community tennis and use of beach club as well.
The 5-Acre private estate with Tennis is in a league of its own in Sag Harbor. Any Two Weeks for $120,000 and other terms available. Be the first to rent this magnificent new build with brand new designer art and furniture. Perched on its own hill, this luxurious estate overlooks 278 acres of manicured golf course and reserve on three sides, for privacy and rolling vistas. The expansive backyard by Marders is bermed for privacy, with an oversized lawn and open vistas. It features a 50' pool with spa, sunbed, waterfall, and firepit. The home spans 3 stories, with 11,000 feet of living space and 7 ensuite bedrooms. High ceilings, 16' sliding glass doors and transom windows contribute a unique sense of light and volume. Other special features include 2 true primary suites (both 1st and 2nd floors), an elevator, custom theater, gym, wine cellar and lower level family room with wetbar (sited off the pool area). The smart home features LED lighting, a 30-speaker sound system, video surveillance and remote-controlled air conditioning and pool. The home is minutes to Long Beach, the Briddge and Noyac Golf Clubs, and local marinas. It is equidistant to Southampton, Sag Harbor, Watermill and Bridgehampton--all options are open for entertaining.
Welcome to your dream rental home! This exquisite new build has just hit the market, offering you a breathtaking living experience. With over 3,700 sq. ft., this spacious home is thoughtfully designed with 4 bedrooms and 4.5 baths, ensuring ample space for you and your loved ones. As you step into the main level, you'll be greeted by an inviting open concept living, dining, and kitchen space. The expansive kitchen features a sizable island, perfect for entertaining and creating unforgettable memories. The primary suite is a true sanctuary, bathed in natural light and adorned with a custom walk-in closet. Indulge in the luxurious bathroom, complete with radiant heat flooring, and step out onto your private deck with direct access to the stunning pool. Two additional bedrooms on the second floor offer privacy and convenience, each with their own en-suite bathrooms. The lower level features a versatile office space, a cozy media room, gym, and a private guest bedroom suite. Prepare to be captivated by the outdoor oasis. Immerse yourself in the 14x32 heated, gunite, saltwater pool with a soothing waterfall feature. The expansive mahogany decking provides ample space for relaxation and entertainment. You'll also find multiple dining areas and cozy lounging spots, perfect for savoring those long summer days. Conveniently located on a tranquil street, this home is just a stone's throw away from Long Beach and Sag Harbor village. Explore the vibrant shopping scene, indulge in art galleries, and savor the culinary delights that Sag Harbor is renowned for. Don't let this opportunity slip away! Be the first to secure this remarkable rental home and start living the life you've always dreamed of. Owner/agent
Rental Registration #: 231003 Four bedroom, two baths contemporary situated on one acre with spacious living /dining room that offers a cathedral ceiling and fireplace. Private backyard with a 20x40 pool, extensive decking & outdoor shower. Located in prestigious North Hampton Colony, a private community with its own beach, marina, waterfront clubhouse, and Clam Island Park. Close proximity to Sag Harbor Village for boating, dining, and shopping.
Welcome to 5 Rogers Court, a stunning modern home located in Sag Harbor, NY, just moments away from Noyac Bay and Long Beach, and only a few minutes from the village. This exquisite property is nestled on a private acre off a tranquil cul-de-sac, surrounded by lush, mature plantings, offering the perfect blend of privacy and luxury coastal living. Boasting 7 bedrooms and 7 and one half baths, this exceptional home spans 4600 square feet on the first and second floor, on over an acre of pristine land. Built to exacting standards, this residence features high-end lighting throughout, creating a warm and inviting ambiance. The property offers 6,500+ square feet of luxury living space spread across three levels, including a heated Gunite pool and spa, perfect for relaxation and entertaining. As you approach the home, you'll be captivated by the striking white gabled silhouette and the tree-lined driveway. Inside, the soaring double-height ship-lapped foyer leads to an open floor plan designed for modern living, with walls of glass seamlessly blending indoor and outdoor spaces. The main level features a Junior Primary suite, a formal powder room, and an expansive mudroom off the 2-car garage, complete with a full cabana bath and laundry facilities. The second level houses the Primary Suite, offering a private balcony, gas fireplace, dual walk-in closets, and a sensational marble spa bath with radiant heat and a soaking tub. Three additional guest suites, one with a private balcony, complete the upstairs living spaces. The lower level is an entertainer's dream, featuring a large recreation and media area, a home gym, two guest rooms, and a shared full bath. Outside, the property boasts a heated Gunite pool and spa, a vast patio surround, a built-in outdoor BBQ, and a serene outdoor shower-perfect for enjoying the beautiful Sag Harbor weather. Don't miss your chance to stay in this extraordinary home yours this summer. Schedule a showing today and experience the epitome of modern luxury living in Sag Harbor.
Rental Registration #: RP240032 Welcome to a luxurious retreat in Northampton Shores waterfront enclave with private bay beach access .5 miles away, where classic Hamptons elegance meets modern comfort. Set among just 22 exclusive homes, this residence offers unparalleled privacy and tranquility, surrounded by the natural beauty of the Peconic Bay, Elizabeth Wildlife Refuge, and Noyac Golf Club. With 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and an array of lavish amenities including a heated gunite pool and outdoor fire pit, this home is designed for sophisticated living and entertaining. The meticulously landscaped backyard and deck provide the perfect setting for outdoor gatherings or serene moments of relaxation. Inside, you'll find a cozy living room with a wood-burning fireplace, a den inspired by Frank Lloyd Wright, and a spacious kitchen and dining area equipped with modern appliances. The primary bedroom suite is a luxurious retreat with a fireplace and spa-inspired ensuite bathroom. Additionally, there are community amenities available such as tennis courts and paddle boards. Just minutes from Sag Harbor village and a short drive from Bridgehampton, Southampton, and East Hampton, residents enjoy easy access to the best of the Hamptons lifestyle, including pristine beaches, gourmet dining, and upscale shopping. Experience the epitome of Hamptons luxury living at this Northampton Shores residence.
Just minutes away from bay beaches, this renovated and very chic beach house is a design maven's dream. The open floor plan features cathedral ceilings, fully retracting doors opening from the living room to the private back yard, three bedrooms plus sleeping loft, and four and a half baths, all meticulously furnished. The chef's kitchen has all the bells and whistles: Viking appliances (giant 48-inch fridge and 54-inch range), custom cabinetry, and butler's pantry. In fact, there is custom everything: woodwork, stone showers and baths, and a 34-foot light fixture designed by Taylor + Miller. This is a SmartHome with Lutron, four-zone HVAC, all controlled from the palm of your hand. Enjoy easy entertaining by the heated gunite pool with sun shelf, and no-splinter Ipe deck with large gas grill. And of course - an outdoor shower! It's close to North Haven's beautiful Sunset Beach, the Village of Sag Harbor, and a short hop to Shelter Island or any of the Hamptons Villages. The perfect summer rental.
Builders own Chic Post Modern with clean lines and top of the line finishes. Minutes to the heart of Sag Harbor Village. Located on a quiet, prestigious street across from bay front estate properties. Tastefully appointed with a contemporary flair, great natural light and open floor plan ideal for entertaining. Gourmet kitchen, cathedral ceilinged great room, TV den. The grand primary suite enjoys one wing of the house while the 4 additional bedrooms occupy the opposite wing. Perfect for families with all of the bedrooms on the same floor the 4 additional bedrooms, 2 that share a Jack & Jill bathroom and 2 that share a hall bathroom. The large sunroom with beautiful double height ceilings and walls of glass is the segway to the fully finished and 50% at ground level walk out finished lower level which features a recreation area, full gym, office area, an additional TV den and full pool bath. There is large upper deck off the great room, mid level stone dining terrace as well as a covered stone patio for al fresco dining by the pool. The completely fenced rear yard with Heated Gunite saltwater pool with the automatic safety cover is a comfort for any parent or pet owner., Mature professionally landscaping and oversized two-car garage. Enjoy the summer in style.
Rental Registration #: 2023-028 Just two miles from Sag Harbor town, twenty minutes from East Hampton, Amagansett and Bridgehampton, and one mile from the Shelter Island ferry, this charming cedar shake home was originally built in the 18th century on the southern side of Sag Harbor and moved to its current location in the early/mid 1900s. It has since been expanded twice to bring it to its current 6+ bedroom, 4 bathroom size. With its mix of antique and modern touches, plus hidden charms, it is a special house where both small and large surprises abound. Rustic details throughout the house bring a sense of turn of the century, while a modernized kitchen, and a mixed modern/rustic dining room, and updated pool area add some current Hampton style. The main bedroom has a king sized bed, an alcove for reading and contemplation, and another bookcase door that opens to a large full bathroom with a washer/dryer, plus a jacuzzi tub to relax in after a long day. There are two more complete bedroom suites on the opposite end of the house with their own full bathrooms, one with a bookcase entry door for extra charm. Three kids bedrooms, one with bunk beds and two with trundle beds that roll out into double twin beds, leave plenty of space for family and guests. There's a child's playroom complete with toys. A tv room on the main floor with access to both the backyard and pool area also has a trundle bed for two more guests. A large, vaulted sunroom with seating is ideal for night time conversation. An inviting screened-in porch that looks out over the backyard and pool area has couches for relaxing, an outdoor dining area, and a projector and drop down screen for watching night time movies or for outdoor enjoyment on rainy days. The large backyard yard has a small basketball court and a movable fire pit with chairs. The beautiful pool area has ample couch seating and lounge chairs plus an outdoor dining area. On one end of the pool area is a lighted screened in gazebo. On the other end is a pool house with barn doors that can open up during the day for access to an inside with a mini kitchen, half bathroom, and seating with a tv. Off site, you can grab one of three kayaks and a paddle board kept down the road by the private community's water access to Sag Harbor Bay and enjoy some nautical time admiring the sights. Long Beach, which is just two miles away, has an expansive beach and view of a great bay where you can also bring the kayaks for daytime trips. When you return from a long day, the winding driveway in front with two entrances can hold a large number of cars. This property is a complete, serene getaway spot for a large family and guests with lots of amenities to help make every day an enjoyable adventure. Other months maybe available, please feel free to make an offer.
Nestled within the heart of North Haven village lies a captivating gated estate sprawled across approximately 3.2 acres of lush open grounds. This remarkable property boasts six bedrooms, six and a half bathrooms, and offers a generous 7500 square feet of living space. With a three-car garage, covered porch, outdoor kitchen, and an expansive gunite pool complemented by impeccable landscaping and a grass tennis court, it presents an idyllic summer retreat. Upon entering the home, you are greeted by an impressive great room adorned with cathedral ceilings and glass doors that open onto an inviting outdoor living space, seamlessly blending indoor and outdoor living. The open-concept chef's kitchen enhances the allure of the main floor. The primary bedroom suite is a sanctuary unto itself, featuring multiple lounging areas and an adjoining office for added convenience. On the second level, you'll discover a stunning junior primary bedroom suite along with guest bedrooms, boasting their own private sitting area. The newly finished lower level offers a fantastic media/recreational space, a gym, game room, and a full bathroom, catering to all your entertainment needs. Outside, the meticulously landscaped grounds provide a picturesque backdrop for the pool and spa, outdoor shower, and ample space for outdoor recreation. Conveniently located, only a stone's throw from Sag Harbor Village's shops and restaurants, this property is the quintessential seasonal retreat.
Beautifully renovated 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath contemporary with bay views. Open floor plan, with professional kitchen, marble countertops and stainless steel appliances. Master bedroom with ensuite bath and home office is located upstairs while three additional bedrooms, including a junior master, are downstairs. You'll also find a second story deck off the kitchen that leads to a heated gunite pool. Short Distance to Long Beach and minutes from Sag Harbor Village!
*No pets* July 1st through August 31st @ $25,000. Must take both months. Fully furnished as shown. Small professionally maintained 4 unit apartment building in the Village of Sag Harbor with one off street parking spot. Walk from town or the Jitney and arrive to your fully furnished and renovated one bedroom apartment in minutes.Included in rental:Furnished with complete kitchen, TV's, Living room, etc. Weekly Garbage & Recycling Pick Up ServiceFree Laundry (washer and dryer) in basementOne off Street Parking SpotShared BackyardGas BBQ in YardFull Grounds MaintenanceAccess to the buildings property manager for routine maintenanceUtilities for Gas & Electric, are NOT included. Cable TV or Wifi is responsibility of tenant.
The 5-Acre private estate with Tennis is in a league of its own in Sag Harbor. Any Two Weeks for $120,000 and other terms available. Be the first to rent this magnificent new build with brand new designer art and furniture. Perched on its own hill, this luxurious estate overlooks 278 acres of manicured golf course and reserve on three sides, for privacy and rolling vistas. The expansive backyard by Marders is bermed for privacy, with an oversized lawn and open vistas. It features a 50' pool with spa, sunbed, waterfall, and firepit. The home spans 3 stories, with 11,000 feet of living space and 7 ensuite bedrooms. High ceilings, 16' sliding glass doors and transom windows contribute a unique sense of light and volume. Other special features include 2 true primary suites (both 1st and 2nd floors), an elevator, custom theater, gym, wine cellar and lower level family room with wetbar (sited off the pool area). The smart home features LED lighting, a 30-speaker sound system, video surveillance and remote-controlled air conditioning and pool. The home is minutes to Long Beach, the Briddge and Noyac Golf Clubs, and local marinas. It is equidistant to Southampton, Sag Harbor, Watermill and Bridgehampton--all options are open for entertaining.
Welcome to your dream rental home! This exquisite new build has just hit the market, offering you a breathtaking living experience. With over 3,700 sq. ft., this spacious home is thoughtfully designed with 4 bedrooms and 4.5 baths, ensuring ample space for you and your loved ones. As you step into the main level, you'll be greeted by an inviting open concept living, dining, and kitchen space. The expansive kitchen features a sizable island, perfect for entertaining and creating unforgettable memories. The primary suite is a true sanctuary, bathed in natural light and adorned with a custom walk-in closet. Indulge in the luxurious bathroom, complete with radiant heat flooring, and step out onto your private deck with direct access to the stunning pool. Two additional bedrooms on the second floor offer privacy and convenience, each with their own en-suite bathrooms. The lower level features a versatile office space, a cozy media room, gym, and a private guest bedroom suite. Prepare to be captivated by the outdoor oasis. Immerse yourself in the 14x32 heated, gunite, saltwater pool with a soothing waterfall feature. The expansive mahogany decking provides ample space for relaxation and entertainment. You'll also find multiple dining areas and cozy lounging spots, perfect for savoring those long summer days. Conveniently located on a tranquil street, this home is just a stone's throw away from Long Beach and Sag Harbor village. Explore the vibrant shopping scene, indulge in art galleries, and savor the culinary delights that Sag Harbor is renowned for. Don't let this opportunity slip away! Be the first to secure this remarkable rental home and start living the life you've always dreamed of. Owner/agent
Just minutes away from bay beaches, this renovated and very chic beach house is a design maven's dream. The open floor plan features cathedral ceilings, fully retracting doors opening from the living room to the private back yard, three bedrooms plus sleeping loft, and four and a half baths, all meticulously furnished. The chef's kitchen has all the bells and whistles: Viking appliances (giant 48-inch fridge and 54-inch range), custom cabinetry, and butler's pantry. In fact, there is custom everything: woodwork, stone showers and baths, and a 34-foot light fixture designed by Taylor + Miller. This is a SmartHome with Lutron, four-zone HVAC, all controlled from the palm of your hand. Enjoy easy entertaining by the heated gunite pool with sun shelf, and no-splinter Ipe deck with large gas grill. And of course - an outdoor shower! It's close to North Haven's beautiful Sunset Beach, the Village of Sag Harbor, and a short hop to Shelter Island or any of the Hamptons Villages. The perfect summer rental.
Enjoy this cozy cottage just minutes from Sag Harbor Main Street with the stores, the restaurants, Steinbeck Park and Long Wharf. Perfect Village-center hideaway with 3 bedrooms and 2 baths and a fabulous back lawn for games galore!
The median Shelter Island, NY rent is $22,000 which is above the national median rent of $1,469. In addition to the rent cost, you need to also account for costs of basic utilities consisting of water, garbage, electric and natural gas. Check with your local Shelter Island utilities for estimates.
There are currently 34 apartments for rent on the Zillow platform in Shelter Island, which fluctuated 0% over the past 30-days.
HotPads amenity filters and keyword searches allow you to target exactly what you're looking for in the Shelter Island, NY area. We surface the largest marketplace of apartment rentals to search through, so you can feel confident you'll find the best available rental in Shelter Island. When new apartment listings come on-market, our recommended searches will notify you in real-time, giving you an advantage to contact landlords and property managers as fast as possible.