34 New Houses for Rent near Shelter Island

Newest Shelter Island, NY Houses Available Now

Page 1 / 2: 34 new houses for rent

Sort: RecommendedSort: NewestSort: Most popularSort: High priceSort: Low price

Apartments

• Favorite button

  Previous imageNext image

  

  New 3d ago

  $95k

  4 beds, 3.5 baths

  47L S Ferry Rd

  House in Shelter Island, NY

• Favorite button

  Previous imageNext image

  

  $22k

  4 beds, 3 baths

  N Cartwright Rd

  House in Shelter Island, NY

• Favorite button

  Previous imageNext image

  

  $20k

  3 beds, 3 baths

  8 Burns Rd

  | Douglas Elliman Real Estate

  House in Shelter Island, NY

• Favorite button

  Previous imageNext image

  

  $110k

  5 beds, 3.5 baths

  21 Harbor Ln

  House in Shelter Island, NY

• Favorite button

  Previous imageNext image

  

  $25k

  4 beds, 3 baths

  20A S Cartwright Rd

  House in Shelter Island, NY

• Favorite button

  Previous imageNext image

  

  $7,500

  4 beds, 3 baths

  7 Peppermill Ln

  | Dering Harbor Real Estate

  House in Shelter Island, NY

23C W Neck Rd

Peppermill Ln

N Cartwright Rd

14 Harbor Ln

116 S Midway Rd

3 Conrad Rd

2 Linda Rd

23 N Midway Rd

25 Smith St

21 Lake Dr

5 Shorewood Rd

99 S Midway Rd

43 Lake Dr

18A S Midway Rd

Rendered Server Side.

Shelter Island Snapshot

Demographic highlights

Total population

2,412 people

Market highlights

Median rent

$22,000

Next page of search results

---

• Price

  • Affordable houses in Shelter Island
  • Luxury houses in Shelter Island

• Beds

  • 2 bedroom houses in Shelter Island
  • 3 bedroom houses in Shelter Island
  • 4+ bedroom houses in Shelter Island

• Property types

  • Apartments for rent in Shelter Island
  • New apartments for rent in Shelter Island
  • Houses for rent in Shelter Island
  • Condos for rent in Shelter Island

• Cities near Shelter Island

  • Town of Southampton houses
  • Groton houses
  • Town of Riverhead houses
  • Town of East Hampton houses
  • New London houses
  • Town of Shelter Island houses
  • North Haven houses
  • Shelter Island Heights houses
  • Sag Harbor houses
  • Noyack houses
  More

• Counties near Shelter Island

  • Kings County houses
  • Queens County houses
  • New York County houses
  • Middlesex County houses
  • Suffolk County houses
  • New London County houses
  • New Haven County houses
  • Washington County houses
  • Tolland County houses
  • Hartford County houses
  More

• Schools near Shelter Island

  • Shelter Island School houses
  • Sag Harbor Elementary School houses
  • Pierson Middle-high School houses
  • Greenport High School houses
  • Greenport Elementary School houses
  • John M. Marshall Elementary School houses
  • East Hampton High School houses
  • East Hampton Middle School houses
  • Southold Junior Senior High School houses
  • Southold Elementary School houses
  More

• Zip codes near Shelter Island

  • 11901 houses
  • 06340 houses
  • 06320 houses
  • 11937 houses
  • 06443 houses
  • 11964 houses
  • 11965 houses
  • 11963 houses
  • 11944 houses
  • 11939 houses
  More