New York's best kept secret is Bay Ridge. It gives you just enough breathing space (being 50% plus surrounded by water)
to feel suburban yet still transcend part of Manhattan's electricity, but for those who can't afford Williamsburg, Bay Ridge is the next best thing.
Red Hook in Brooklyn is another low-key neighborhood that has yet to blow up. Likely because there's no train into the neighborhood, you'd have to take buses.
*This was voted the best answer from our community of users, not an answer, opinion or advice from HotPads.