9 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964 | HotPads


5 beds
4.5 baths
2,744 sqft

Prospect Avenue
Shelter Island, NY 11964


  • Updated 7 days ago
  • Oil Heating
  • Pool: On-site
Classic rambling Heights house has room for all - five bedrooms, each with a distinctive character and spacious, airy common rooms on the first floor with two ornamental fireplaces, which open to a delightful veranda with slices of water views. The rear offers a lovely pool, almost a surprise, since pools are so uncommon in the Heights. There are two side lawns to enjoy lawn games and ping pong table on the porch. Three bikes are available to tool around the island at your leisure. With access to Beach Club, this is a very special rental! Two week rental minimum.
Property amenities
  • Architecture Style: Victorian
  • Heating system: Forced Air
  • Heating: Oil
  • MLS Listing ID: 45856
  • Swimming Pool
  • View Type: Water View
    Pricing comparison
    At $15,000, this listing is priced $6,600 cheaper than the current market rate for a 5 bedroom home in Shelter Island Heights.
    Other 5 bedroom homes...
  • in Shelter Island Heights go for $21,600
  • in Suffolk County go for $25,050
  • in 11965 go for $21,750
  • Nearby schools
    Students who live in Prospect Avenue attend the following SHELTER ISLAND UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT (Unified School District) public schools:
    out of 10
    Shelter Island School
    Grades K - 12
    1.5 miles
    Showing 1 of 1 school.
    Disclaimer: Historically, GreatSchools ratings have been based solely on a comparison of standardized test results for all schools in a given state. As of September 2017, the GreatSchools ratings also incorporate additional information, when available, such as college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. GreatSchools ratings are designed to be a starting point to help parents compare schools, and they should not be the only factor used in selecting the right school for your family. Learn more.
    You are contacting
    Penelope Moore
    Member since Apr 2017
    We value your privacy - see our privacy policy and terms of use
    Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity
    © 2018 HotPads